Skip to main content

The Best Car Insurance For Millennials

7 minute read

By Devon Taylor

Millennials, also known as Generation Y, are the demographic sandwiched between Generation X and Generation Z. They are typically considered to be propleg born between 1981 to 1996. Most Millennials are the children of baby boomers and early Generation Xers. Today, most Millennials are between the ages of 25 and 40. They are working, raising young families, and likely driving almost everywhere they go. Many Millennials are on the lookout for the best car insurance. Whether you want better coverage or cheaper premiums, there are plenty of competitive offers to choose from. In this article, we look at the best car insurance for Millennials.

Clearcover Insurance

Clearcover Insurance is an innovative company that uses technology to save Millennials money on their automotive coverage. They cut out most of the marketing (and even real people). Instead, they use artificial intelligence to offer really cheap insurance rates.

You can apply for their car insurance using an online app. It will tell you almost instantly whether you qualify or not. Clearcover also lets you file claims using the same app. You can describe what happened and even upload photos or videos of any damage directly from your cellphone. They don’t even require an insurance adjuster when claims are filed!

Source: Clearcover

California Casualty

Millennials who have dedicated their lives to public service should consider getting their car insurance from California Casualty. The company (that’s actually based in Colorado Springs, Colorado) offers special discounts to anyone who works as a first responders or are engaged in civic pursuits.

Firefighters, paramedics, nurses, police officers, educators, and certain college employees are all eligible to get significant discounts on their car insurance from California Casualty. Discounts can range from 10-to-25%, depending on your driving record. If you are a Millennial who work on the frontlines, you should definitely checkout California Casualty.

Source: California Casualty

Say Insurance

One of the secrets of the insurance industry is that your rate is based on your “insurance score.” This is a composite calculation based on a number of things. Your driving record, claims history, and credit score are all factored in. Unfortunately, most people have no idea what their insurance score is. Or how it’s calculated.

Since the insurance industry is happy to keep your score a secret, many Millennials are left wondering why their premiums are so high — especially if they have a fairly clean driving record. Say Insurance promises to demystify the process by revealing you insurance score when you apply. It will even offer tips on your could improve it. The better your score, the lower your premiums will be.

Source: Say Insurance


Metromile bills itself as “pay per mile car insurance.” It offers some of the best car insurance for Millennials who work from home, have a short commute, or simply prefer walking or biking to get where they are going. This low cost pay-per-mile insurance charges a base rate of $29 (and up) per month, plus a few cents for each mile driven.

Many Metromile customers end up paying $50 or less a month. The company also includes pet injury coverage with collision and comprehensive coverage on all of its policies. If you’ve recently embraced the work from home lifestyle and have no plans to go back to the office full time, consider Metromile. Why pay all that insurance for a car that barely leaves the parking spot anymore?


Amica Mutual Insurance

For sheer cost savings, it’s hard to beat Amica Mutual Insurance. It consistently ranks as one of the best insurance companies when it comes to customer service and satisfaction. Millennials will not only love the money they save with Amica, but also the money they get back.

Since it’s a mutual company, Amica is able to give its customers some money back every year in the form of a dividend payment. The company’s dividend policies typically pay 5-to-20% of your premiums back to you, annually. If you enjoy getting cashback rewards from your credit or insurance products, check Amica Mutual Insurance.


State Auto Insurance

For truly comprehensive coverage, look no further than State Auto Insurance. Surveys show that roughly 70% of Millennials own a pet. And almost every single Millennials owns a smartphone. State Auto protects them both (along with your vehicle, of course), at no extra cost.

State Auto’s “AutoXtended” policy not only protects the family pet in the event of an accident, it also covers damage to any phones. It will also cover emergency travel expenses, bail bonds, locksmith or key replacement, emergency ambulance transportation, and even disability coverage. Now that’s comprehensive coverage!

Source: State Auto

Verti Insurance

Insurance companies that rely on artificial intelligence might be good at providing cost savings. However, they can lack a human touch. After a stressful incident like a car crash, it can be helpful to have the guidance of a helpful human being.

Verti Insurance prides itself on offering car insurance in its home state of Pennsylvania. Not only do they have low premiums, but also a dedicated Personal Advisor service. It makes a real human available to phone, text, or email at any time — day or night. Verti also has a decent app, that provides one-tap access to help in an emergency. However, it’s their personal service that really shines.

Source: Verti

Safeco Insurance

Safeco is a highly rated insurance company that is actually owned by Liberty Mutual. It offers a lot of options, designed specifically to fit the lives of Millennials. Notably, safe drivers can save up to 30% with the company’s “RightTrack” policy. It’s a smartphone app that tracks your driving (acceleration, braking, total miles driven) and rewards safe drivers with lower rates.

Additionally, pet owners can add pet coverage to almost all Safeco policies. Part-time Uber and Lyft drivers can also get low-cost “RideSharing” coverage to protect themselves while using their vehicle as a source of income. With more Millennials embracing the “gig economy,” you may want to look into Safeco Insurance.


Root Insurance

Root Insurance is all about the app. The company has developed a very advanced app, with lots of bells and whistles. Root Insurance’s app will track your driving habits, give you an instant quote, and lets your file claims directly and call roadside assistance.

Since the company only insures drivers it deems safe, their rates tend to be super low for those who qualify. Root Insurance says many of their customers save over 50% compared to their old insurance rates. That’s an average annual saving of $1,187. That’s a decent chunk of money for any Millennial. Just remember that you need a sparkling record in order to get this discount.


Good2Go Insurance

Good2Go Insurance provides affordable insurance for young drivers or those with banged-up driving records. Specializing in state-minimum insurance with low premiums and deductibles, Good2Go also offers a discount for those who use the “LifeSaver” distracted-driving app.

While not for everyone, Good2Go could be a great choice for younger Millennials with a limited driving history or a few accidents on their record already. Finding affordable car insurance after a few claims can be tough, so Good2Go might be exactly what you need.

Source: Good2Go

Elephant Insurance

Elephant is one of the best car insurance companies for cost conscious young drivers. They offer discounts that can reach as high as 40%, if you meet certain criteria. These discounts are given out for a variety of things, including going paperless, making on time payments, having a good driving record, and more.

Young drivers who are just starting out can save big bucks with Elephant Insurance. The discounts aren’t only based on your driving record or insurance score either, which is a great bonus. You can save money just by asking them to not mail you a paper statement every month or by always paying on time. That’s pretty sweet!

Source: Elephant

Empower Insurance

Texas-based Empower Insurance has been in business since 2003. The company is actually run by a group of Generation Z founders. However, it’s primarily focused on providing car insurance to Millennials — particularly those with bad credit.

Empower Insurance can provide you with coverage even if you have bad credit. That’s because the majority of their insurance polices don’t take your credit score into consideration when calculating premiums. They remove the credit check from the qualify process altogether. Although it’s a bit riskier, this approach allows Empower to insure those who might not otherwise qualify for affordable car insurance.

Source: Empower

Lemonade Insurance

Lemonade Insurance is another newer company making waves. Like some others on this list, they save money by not having local offices. Instead, everything is done online. They’ve already impressed the Millennial market by offering home, life, renters, and pet insurance. Luckily for us, they also recently added auto insurance to their offerings too.

If you already use Lemonade for another insurance need, you can bundle your car insurance in and save even more. They offer the same competitive pricing, online convenience, and quick claims and payout system on their car insurance products as they do on their original policies. Some of their car insurance plans are as little as $30 per month (depending on your circumstances, of course). Millennials already love Lemonade for their other insurance needs. Check out their auto plans!

Source: Lemonade

Devon Taylor

Managing Editor

Devon is an experienced writer and a father of three young children. He's simultaneously trying to build college funds and plan for an eventual retirement. He's been in online publishing since 2013 and has a degree from the University of Guelph. In his free time, he loves fanatically following the Blue Jays and Toronto FC, running, camping with his family, and playing video games.

Explore Auto Insurance

How To Buy Car Insurance: The Best Tips and Tricks Auto Insurance

How To Buy Car Insurance: The Best Tips and Tricks

You can now buy car insurance completely online (or even using an app). For those that prefer the traditional way, you can still buy your auto insurance through a local broker. There are a variety of discounts available — if you know what to ask for. The best way to get cheaper car insurance is […]

Read More about How To Buy Car Insurance: The Best Tips and Tricks

8 minute read

Easy Ways To Lower Your Car Insurance Premiums Auto Insurance

Easy Ways To Lower Your Car Insurance Premiums

Paying less for your monthly (or annual) car insurance premiums involves a variety of factors. Driving safe and frequent comparison shopping are the two biggest ways to lower your costs. Don’t be afraid to switch car insurance companies — they are all mostly the same, anyway. Money-saving tactics are the subject of hundreds of Google […]

Read More about Easy Ways To Lower Your Car Insurance Premiums

7 minute read

Car Insurance For High Risk Drivers: The Best Options Auto Insurance

Car Insurance For High Risk Drivers: The Best Options

High risk drivers are typically those with a history of accidents or tickets. New (or younger) drivers, with no driving history, are often considered riskier by insurance companies. High risk drivers generally pay more for their car insurance. That makes shopping around for a good price even more important. When you apply for car insurance, […]

Read More about Car Insurance For High Risk Drivers: The Best Options

9 minute read



The New 2022 Chevy Silverado: An Early Look Research and Reviews

The New 2022 Chevy Silverado: An Early Look

The new 2022 Chevy Silverado 1500 is set to hit dealerships in the spring. The starting price is $30,400 and goes up considerably from there. Nine trims are available, each with a unique set of features and upgrades. If you’re looking to purchase a new truck for work or off-roading adventures, the new Chevrolet Silverado […]

Read More about The New 2022 Chevy Silverado: An Early Look

6 minute read




The Best New Full-Sized Trucks for 2022 Research and Reviews

The Best New Full-Sized Trucks for 2022

Full-size pickup trucks come in different weight classes, but most people can find all they need with a half-ton truck. You can find engine options for a wide range of needs, whether you’re looking for fuel efficiency, additional towing and hauling capability or off-road ability. If you want the maximum capability when shopping for a […]

Read More about The Best New Full-Sized Trucks for 2022

7 minute read